BEST OF NYC

Best Specialty Grocers

By
Coolstuff Team
January 16, 2026

One of the greatest parts about living in NYC is the fact that at any given moment, you could head out in search of rare, specific ingredients, and find exactly what you want within the five boroughs. One of the ways this benefit is possible is on the backs of the city’s long history of specialty grocers - and as lovers of food and culture, these are actually some of our favorite places to shop in the city.

Russo’s

Park Slope, Brooklyn & East Village, Manhattan

Photo by Documenting America

With three locations across Brooklyn and Manhattan, Russo’s has all things Italian American. From freshly sliced cured meats & cheeses to housemade mozzarella, and tons of prepared food items (including rotisserie chicken at the 5th avenue location in Park Slope.) 

When we’re hosting friends for dinner, we always stop at Russo’s to pick up aperitivo supplies and get the night started off right.

Zabar’s

Upper West Side, Manhattan

What is there to say about the legendary grocer whose aisles have graced the screen in classics like You’ve Got Mail? Known for their coffee, babka, and smoked salmon, Zabar’s second floor is stocked with some of the best kitchen supplies money can buy.

Un Posto Italiano

Park Slope, Brooklyn

While Russo’s has you covered on Italian-American staples, you can fill the void still left in your cupboard with the tight edit of imported Italian products. Our favorites include their perfect butter and a bag of fennel taralli crackers. While you’re here don’t forget to stop and sip on an espresso made from Hausbrandt beans (also available for purchase).

Big Night

Upper East Side • West Village • Greenpoint

Are you looking for the hottest new brands in food? How about wonderfully curated glassware and hosting needs? Cool stuff favorite Big Night is a reliable pick when you don’t know what you want but need it to be the best – especially with locations uptown, downtown, and in Brooklyn. 

Kalustyan’s

Murray Hill, Manhattan

This Armenian mecca of spices has been operating on Lexington Avenue since 1944 and is a staple of the city’s gourmands for a reason. Across its sprawling and meandering two floors of product you’ll find hundreds of specialty pantry ingredients you didn’t know existed – from 20 types of popcorn to an entire aisle of dried edible flowers. Given the large Indian population of the neighborhood, Kalyustyan’s is also a great place to shop for harder to find ingredients from South Asia like lime pickle or papadam.

Sahadi’s

Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn • Sunset Park, Brooklyn

After the building of the Brooklyn Battery Tunnel, many of those in the former Little Syria neighborhood displaced by the construction ended up just across the East River along Atlantic Avenue. Among them were the Sahadi family who first opened a Lebanese grocer in the city in 1895. The current iteration, which has been in Brooklyn since the 1940s, is still a destination for bulk nuts and candies, middle eastern staples, and their wonderful hot bar in the back. Recently, Sahadi’s opened a second outpost in Sunset Park’s Industry City, complete with a wine shop that carries a handful of Lebanese wines.

Ten Ichi Mart

Flatiron • Williamsburg • West Village • Cobble Hill • Astoria 

While there are a few players shops that stock a similar assortment of Japanese groceries and snacks (shout out to Mitsuki and Sunrise Mart) our favorite to visit is Ten Ichi for always having a great curation and delicious freshly prepared foods.

Mercado Central

Cobble Hill & Gowanus, Brooklyn

Across its two Brooklyn stores, Mercado Central offers Spanish goods from every region of the culinarily diverse country. This dedication has been recognized by the country itself and Mercado Central is an official Spanish Colmado. Shop tons of tinned seafood, cured jamon, and even beers and ciders from some of the country’s best breweries.

Edy’s Grocer

Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Our favorite part of cool friend Edy Massih’s eponymous Lebanese grocery (aside from the fun spirit that flows through the place) are the immaculate array of house-made dips and spreads. Stop in to fill your fridge and spice cabinet, and grab a sandwich to go while you’re at it…then thank us later.

New Kam Man Market

Chinatown, Mahattan

For years, this Chinatown grocer has been our relative secret. While it’s located on a particularly busy block of Canal street, the entrance is a little awkward and that’s our theory as to why it isn’t as bustling as nearby Hong Kong Supermarket. If you’re looking for produce, meats, or seafood, New Kam Man is not your place…HOWEVER along three stories you’ll find an abundance of pantry ingredients, porcelain homewares, appliances, and an amazing selection of tea, incense and beauty. If you’re hungry, grab a snack from the food counter near the door on your way out.

Photo by Lukas on Google Maps

Tashkent

West Village, Manhattan • Brighton Beach • Kensington • Forest Hills

In many ways, the increasingly popular Tashkent empire operates like any other grocery store: among its aisles you’ll find Heinz 57 and familiar brands of oat milk BUT its hot bar is truly like no other. Refilled often and always warm, you can feast on manty dumplings, kebabs, salads, and lots of pastries (both sweet and savory).

About